“Give me a girl at an impressionable age and she is mine for life.”

Brown Baggers read and discussed “The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie” (1962) by Muriel Spark on October 15th.  For a few it was a re-read, and 5 had seen the 1969 film and declared the film superior to the book due to Maggie Smith’s portrayal of the title character.

Miss Jean Brodie is a spinster teacher at a girls’ school in Edinburgh in the pre-WWII 1930s. Supposedly Miss Brodie lost her fiance Hugh in WWI. Our readers wondered if Hugh really existed? Did Miss Brodie give up on love to dedicate herself to the girls? Miss Brodie rebelled against the school’s curriculum, the headmaster and the school’s emphasis on team spirit.

The plot foreshadows a betrayal of Miss Brodie by one of her students. Miss Brodie’s charismatic personality gave her influence on the Brodie set of girls at a critical time in their young lives.  

Miss Brodie professes admiration of Mussolini and Hitler. Was Spark being satiric?Was this to warn of admiration of dictators? Sandy (one of her students who later becomes a nun) felt Miss Brodie was a danger to weaker minded students. Miss Brodie has romantic dalliances with both the school’s art teacher, Mr. Lloyd and the music teacher, Mr. Lowther.  Despite herself, Miss Brodie gives her girls the confidence to each go their own way.

Readers felt the book was well written and admired the flash forwards and the balance of specificity and vagueness of the plot. On deeper reflection, some readers felt the book brings up big questions of politics and religion.

Readers asked ourselves, How do you know when you are in your prime?

Do some people have multiple primes?

One of our readers had read more on Muriel Spark’s family life and personal background which  added context and provided new insights into our discussion. There was definitely an intersection of Miss Brodie’s story with that of the author, making it semi-autobiographical. 

Readers wondered why this book was so popular? (It’s been listed in numerous “best novel” lists.) Was it because it was considered risque at the time?

There was a general discussion of teachers who have been influential in the lives of some of the members of the group and how this made an impact on them.

Other titles mentioned:

Upcoming titles:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *